A University of Chicago law professor disclosed on November 9 that Claude deleted a full year of class notes, all of which were restored from cloud storage
The professor had only asked for page numbers to be updated in old lecture notes, but instead of editing, Claude deleted the 2023 class notes in the top level directory along with the current term syllabus, and the model admitted the error before the user noticed and asked whether it should attempt recovery
On November 9, William Baude, a well known scholar of United States constitutional law and a professor at the University of Chicago Law School, disclosed an AI operating error. He had only asked Anthropic assistant Claude to update the page numbers in an older set of constitutional law lecture notes, but on returning from lunch he found that Claude had deleted a full year of class notes along with the syllabus for the current term.
Baude posted the story on a social platform on November 6 and attached a screenshot of Claude admitting the mistake. In its reply, Claude said that while reviewing the materials it found a page reference error but failed to modify the lecture notes, and instead mistakenly deleted other important files. The model admitted the error before the user noticed it, said it had not taken any remedial action, and then asked Baude whether he could restore the deleted files from cloud storage or whether it should attempt recovery itself.
Unlike ordinary chatbots, agents that can directly operate a computer and its files can cause important data to be deleted or overwritten when judgment fails or permissions are misconfigured. Fortunately there was no permanent loss here, as Baude later restored every deleted file through cloud storage. The episode underlines the need for backups when granting agents access to and modification rights over files.